| The Purchase dorm
fire
(Original publication: February 27,
2004)
There are three
important facets to the safety issues rising from the smoke of
a Feb. 12 fire in a Purchase College, SUNY, dormitory: the
need for sprinklers in student housing regardless of a
building's age; addresssing the long-standing danger of
furniture that easily catches fire; and educating students and
college personnel about fire safety.
The issues affect all residential facilities that house
students, campers and others, not just Purchase College, which
saw 260 students displaced in the suspicious fire but,
fortunately, only minor injuries. As John A. Viniello of
Patterson, president of the National Fire Sprinkler
Association Inc., said in a letter to the editor last week,
that was thanks to the quick work of the Purchase, Port
Chester and West Harrison fire departments.
Even though the Farside dormitory at Purchase was "up to
code,'' it did not have sprinklers ready to go off in a fire
on any floor but the basement. Built in 1972, the dorm is not
required to have the latest technology in fire prevention. The
fact that such safety steps have been avoided through
"grandfathering'' is senseless.
The building did have fire- and smoke-detection alarm
systems, one of a series of recommendations by a state task
force after a 2000 fire at Seton Hall University, N.J., killed
three people. But unless buildings are undergoing major
renovations, or new ones are going up, water-spraying devices
are not installed in most colleges.
The chief of the New York State University Police told The
Journal News that college officials were planning to ask the
state for estimates on installing sprinklers in all dorms, but
they did not know when or how much money they would get for
the project.
Viniello suggested that the retrofitting costs could be
passed on as a small surcharge on room and board fees. We
believe this is a state, college and insurer responsibility.
According to the National Fire Protection Association, on
average, direct property damage per fire is 41 percent lower
in dormitory fires where sprinklers are present. Doesn't it
make sense to invest in sprinklers? To save property — and
lives?
Meanwhile, police and others are conducting an arson
investigation into the Farside fire. Westchester Crime
Stoppers is offering a reward of up to $5,000 for information
leading to an arrest.
Campus speculation is that someone deliberately set a couch
on fire, which leads to Issue No. 2: new fire standards for
foam furniture.
For years, the State Association of Fire Chiefs has been
advocating that New York adopt far higher furniture standards
that include requiring that cover fabric resists an open flame
for one second; and that polyurethane foam, present in about
90 percent of upholstered furniture, be treated with
fire-retardant chemicals.
Firefighters call the foam "liquid gasoline." The U.S.
Consumer Product Safety Commission continues to drag its feet
on addressing the danger, known for an incredible three
decades.
Finally, as The Journal News reported, false alarms on
campuses are quite common. There always is the danger that
even the most safety-conscious residents will ignore them.
According to Purchase Fire Chief Joseph Brefere, some of the
Farside students resisted evacuation the night of the fire by
hiding in their rooms and had to be removed by force. Another
third-floor student was sleeping when found by firefighters.
Clearly, campuses must step up fire-prevention efforts,
including awareness and education for every single student.
That has to include more vigilance from students and staff in
reporting pranks and mischief, and strict enforcement of
penalties for offenders.
But there also must be greater attention devoted to
spotting and reporting troubled students who threaten
fire-setting or other risky behavior.
According to Ed Comeau, director of the Center for Campus
Fire Safety in Massachusetts, about one-third of campus fires
across the country are caused by arson. That's chilling.
He also told staff writer David Novich that many students
light fires to try to get attention or cause mischief, without
the intention of causing physical harm. Regardless of intent,
that's a sign of sickness. Ignoring it is foolhardy.
|